The length of multiple football fields end to end, and with ceilings as high as ten stories, an aircraft hangar might house hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of aviation assets on any given day.
Since 1951, the designers and engineers of FSB have begun each federal, commercial and private hangar project by asking clients the same questions—“How many aircraft will need access to your hangar? What types?”
When a client expresses a need for his or her hangar to be flexible enough to store different types of planes on different days, for example, two wide-body Boeing 777s on Monday and five small regional jets on Friday, the firm may offer an option for a long span hangar, the “open concept” of aircraft hangars, where designers minimize the use of support columns for an unobstructed, flexible space within. Any hangar with a clear span greater than 250 feet of columnless space classifies as long span, but FSB has also designed hangars with more than 500 feet between columns.
“Most clients prefer the flexibility of long span, but it does come with a cost,” FSB President and Aviation Market Principal Philip McNayr said. McNayr has strengthened the firm’s deep portfolio of aviation facility projects for more than 40 years. “Owners who choose long span do so because the open space allows them operational flexibility to maintain aircraft in an economic way.”
Determining whether a hangar needs to be long span is one of many decisions through which FSB guides its clients during the design process. A need for flexibility leads some clients to long span design, and each owner brings a unique set of additional requirements to their hangar project—geographic limitations, type of maintenance, timelines, budget, height restrictions, access to materials, potential expansion needs, to name a few. Each requirement plays a role in driving the final design, McNayr said.
Tailor materials and design to available resources
When a major United States airline approached the firm with a project to design a hangar in Brazil, the airline knew it would need to be long span. Budget and timeline were also major considerations that influenced the design. On top of this, the materials and construction techniques dictated in the design would need to work with local building codes, customs and available resources.
“The design substituted precast concrete where in the United States we would have used steel,” Senior Structural Engineer Min Koo said. Koo is a core team member for the Aviation Design Team and has more than 14 years of experience in hangar design with FSB. “In the United States labor costs are high, and concrete requires more labor than steel, which makes concrete the more expensive material. In Brazil, labor is less expensive so concrete is more affordable, and steel is very expensive due to a limited number of steel manufacturers and available steel shapes.”
Koo also based his design upon the sizes and connection types customary in Brazil in order to keep costs down and make the structure easier to build. He said FSB researched the local building codes and hired a Brazilian architectural and engineering firm to assist them in understanding customs, techniques and available materials. As a company accustomed to working in other parts of the world, this type of cultural research and local partner work is often part of FSB’s process. In this case, the local firm will finalize FSB’s concept and prepare more detailed construction documents based on the design created by FSB.
To honor the owner’s budget and timeline constraints, Koo also incorporated pre-engineered metal building components into the design where possible to save time and money during construction.
Design for aesthetics, engineer for resilience
When the North Island Naval Air Station needed a helicopter maintenance hangar built for its Pacific Fleet, the Naval Facilities Engineering Command knew flexibility would be paramount. Structurally, the North Island’s soft soil combined with the area’s frequent seismic activity made for an engineering challenge. For a site location visible from the San Diego Bay, the base commander said aesthetics were also a priority—it would need to be unique and beautiful, not a box. North Island Naval Air Station is known as the birthplace of naval aviation, and the final design needed to live up to this heritage.
“We added curved forms along the roof lines to move the design away from the appearance of a simple box,” Koo said. “The shape is inspired by the waves of the adjacent San Diego Bay.”
To structurally stabilize the hangar, stone columns were placed into the soft soil as a foundation. Specialized bracing systems and shear walls were applied to ready the building to withstand high seismic forces. For his structural team’s creative solutions to the site’s particularly challenging geography, FSB received the 2014 Excellence in Structural Engineering Award – Outstanding Project from the National Council of Structural Engineers Associations.
“I appreciate FSB’s diligence in reaching a stretch goal under less than ideal circumstances,” Deputy Operations Officer Captain Andy Schulman said. “I am very impressed with how they brought it all together.”
Pull from past experience and across disciplines
Clients working with FSB soon discover they are in adept, knowledgeable hands. The firm’s 75 years of experience designing hangars combined with their in-house architectural, civil, structural, mechanical, fire protection and electrical engineers make for a nimble, sizable team able to produce excellent, well-coordinated work between disciplines on a tight timeline.
For Koo, the motivation is simple.
“We care about our clients’ needs, and work to find them the best solution.”
Interested in learning more from the aircraft maintenance facility experts, contact Laure Majors at firstname.lastname@example.org or call her direct at 405.840.2931.